The very smart Petra Marquardt-Bigman pulls some threads together here.
You can't say the same for Richard Silverstein, however, who responds to criticism which he doesn't even seem able to understand, here. Read the comments from Mark Gardner and Alex Stein too.
UPDATE More on the unbelievable Silverstein from David T here.
More responses to Mumbai
Added by David Hirsh on December 07, 2008 08:11:05 PM.